Evolving.
How do you give help when they won't take it?
Published on December 14, 2004 By Angloesque In Home & Family
I started to blog under the title "This whole job thing is seriously cutting down my blog time," but since then have had a phone call from my mother. Here are the contents of that phone call. Numbers 1 and 4 are of particular importance to my point.

1) Starting with the moral of this number's story: Old people shouldn't drive. My step-grandmother struck another car head-on 18 months ago, sending the driver to the ICU. Yesterday he served her with papers: seeking medical damages (past and future), lost wages (past and future), and emotional damages or whatever they call that. She, of course, doesn't think it was her fault; she can't figure out why he was in her lane (he wasn't), why he wasn't wearing a seatbelt (he was), and why he would want to sue her. And we all know it's her fault, and we had been trying to stop her from driving for a long time, and moreover we're so thankful the man wasn't killed. (Literally hid her keys, were her taxi service, told her over and over not to drive, called her doctor and her insurance company, etc.) We were all afraid something like this would happen, and it has, and we're all biting the "I told you so" retort on our lips.

[begin tangential phone conversation news]

2) My grandpa's brother's wife (so my step-great-aunt)'s daughter was sleeping in her bed Sunday morning when a tree fell on her house, the trunk of which landed about 10 feet from her. So she called my step-great-aunt, who got into the car and stopped to grab some chicken on the way there (sustenance food, apparently)--

3) and at the drive-through, she placed her order but didn't hear anyone say anything, so step-great-aunt kept asking, "Are you there? Is someone there?" and after a couple minutes, someone came on and said, "I'm sorry. My husband just dropped dead." The ambulance came, there was a whole ordeal, etc. (Apparently it was a husband/wife fried chicken joint. Now it's just a wife's fried chicken joint)

[/tangent]

4) And most disturbingly, my psychotic 33-year-old cousin ran away. Long story short, every one in the family has tried to help him get some medical and psychological treatment; and as each person tries to help him, he turns against them. Now he has left a note, taken his ID and nothing else, not even his car ("so you can't trace me"), and disappeared. We don't think he's a danger to other people, but what if he is, and what if he does something stupid and deadly or stupid and violent? How can we search for someone who doesn't want to be found, take home someone who doesn't want to go home, give care to someone who doesn't want care, or help someone who asks for it, but won't take what is offered?

And so I close my dilemma in a better author's words:

"'Help,' he said, 'is giving part of yourself to somebody who comes to accept it willingly and needs it badly.'

"'And so it is,' he said, using an old homiletic transition, 'that we can seldom help anybody. Either we don't know what part to give or maybe we don't like to give any part of ourselves. Then, more often than not, the part that is needed is not wanted. And even more often, we do not have the part that is needed.'"


Frustratingly,

Angloesque

Comments
on Dec 14, 2004
Yes, this is a dilemna. There is a phrase about leading a horse to water that might fit as well. But on the plus side, at least grandma shouldn't be driving after this, and no one was killed to get the point across. As for the title you didn't use, I can't speak for anyone else, but I'll enjoy what blogs you do manage to write.
on Dec 14, 2004
"'Help,' he said, 'is giving part of yourself to somebody who comes to accept it willingly and needs it badly.'

"'And so it is,' he said, using an old homiletic transition, 'that we can seldom help anybody. Either we don't know what part to give or maybe we don't like to give any part of ourselves. Then, more often than not, the part that is needed is not wanted. And even more often, we do not have the part that is needed.'"


I've never heard that before, but I found it to be very insightful. I'm sorry about the rough spots you are dealing with with your family. Best wishes to you and yours.
on Dec 14, 2004
I think the authorities ought to test the eye sight and reflexes of elderly drivers, maybe once a year or two years.

>>and at the drive-through, ((snip)) ..The ambulance came, there was a whole ordeal, etc

hm talk about timing.

>> "'Help,' he said, 'is giving part of yourself to somebody who comes to accept it willingly and needs it badly.'

That's true. You can't force help on someone who doesn't want to be helped. It's a very difficult family situation. He seems to need some help and from what you say, he probably doesn't think so.
on Dec 14, 2004
Danny: Yeah, you'd think my grandma wold get the hint by now. But she doesn't. Fortunately, this time our calls won't fall on a deaf ear at her insurance agency.

TW: Isn't that a great quote? I wish I'd written it. Best wishes to you and yours, too.

Raven: Last year my students debated elderly drivers, but they had a hard time justifying adding these kinds of tests to elderly drivers and finding a suitable age to do so, since it varies so much. As for my cousin*, we think he knows he needs help but he isn't willing to take the first step. He asks for help but gets belligerant when we suggest something. It's disappointing and energy-leeching.

*Have to admit that I'm a little relieved to not be related to my grandmother's dementia or my cousins psychosis, as they're both step-relations.

-A.
on Dec 14, 2004


This is one of those blogs that, while reading, I can't help but say to myself "No way. No freaking way."

I, too, have wrestled with the issue of elderly drivers for the very same reasons you mentioned. Where do you draw the lines? It is so different for everybody, and to be honest I think they should just have some vision and reaction testing for everyone. I see plenty of people my age who drive like idiots. Weed them out as well, then we aren't discriminating by age.

I have a hard time with the help thing. I think pretty analytically, so will often see a solution before those around me, and it will seem obvious. So I have to sit back, bite my tongue, and wait for them to want my help. Darn frustrating sometimes.
on Dec 14, 2004

3) and at the drive-through, she placed her order but didn't hear anyone say anything, so step-great-aunt kept asking, "Are you there? Is someone there?" and after a couple minutes, someone came on and said, "I'm sorry. My husband just dropped dead." The ambulance came, there was a whole ordeal, etc. (Apparently it was a husband/wife fried chicken joint. Now it's just a wife's fried chicken joint)


Well, maybe if they weren't serving Fried Chicken in the MORNING, he'd still be around now, wouldn't he? (sorry, couldn't resist).

on Dec 14, 2004
Well, maybe if they weren't serving Fried Chicken in the MORNING, he'd still be around now, wouldn't he? (sorry, couldn't resist).


I have to admit that this story is just too bizarre for my logic to comprehend. I heard it third-hand, from my mom from my grandparents, so I'm sure there are some issues with it. (The aforementioned grandma probably did the storytelling, and as I've not-too-subtly insinuated, she's not the brightest bulb.) However, while the details and timing may be messed up, the facts are true. What a shitty day this past Sunday was.

-A.