Evolving.
Currently there is a US-led offensive in the Iraqi town of Najaf--you have to deliberately ignore the news to not notice that. Najaf is probably what you'd call a mecca, a holy place, and it is home to the Iman Ali shrine and a vast cemetary, the Wadi-us-Salaam (ironically means "Valley of Peace").

And now there are US soldiers, tanks, and helicopters swarming the city, trying to, depending on the way you look at it, put down Shiite uprisings or inflict an an American presence on their way of life. (Aside: When did Iraqis go from being "Iraqis" or "Shiites" to "insurgents"? And it makes a damned fine line for the US and our, can we still call it this, coalition to walk.

The thing that gets me is that this mosque is so holy, and yet there are Shiites fighting from inside it. If it's so holy and they don't want it damaged, why risk its destruction? Ah. To incite rebellion. To get the US or Iragi forces to bomb it, ruin it, and piss off even more Shiites. What they're doing, in effect, is hiding behind their religion. And according to their beliefs (or ancient beliefs--don't know whether they're held today or not), if you're buried in Najaf, you'll definitely go to heaven.

But if the roles were reversed, would we in America be any different? Arguably, if Najaf is the Holy Place for the Shiites, and stands for what they believe, is the Statue of Liberty the American equivalent? Or was that the World Trade Center? Or the White House? Arlington Cemetary? Veitnam Memorial? The new WWII memorial? Seattle Space Needle? St. Louis arch?

Where would you be holding your gun? NYC? McDonald's Golden arches?

Comments
on Aug 12, 2004
I wouold say Hollywood would be the cultural centre of the USA!!! but thats just me...

I hate it how they hide behind their 'Jihad'

All they are doing is antagonising US forces so that other Arab nations get involved... it's a shame really...

Good Blog.

BAM!!!
on Aug 13, 2004
Hollywood? Well, yes, we're all stars and beautiful and eat salads with the correct utensils.

Personally, I don't think there is a US equivalent. I realized this morning that Najaf doesn't speak for all Iraqis--just the Shiites. The equivalent for Shiites in the US would be, what, Baptists? They're the biggest hard-liners I know. Maybe LDS (Mormons). Or Catholics, but that's more universal than American. Hmm. Still thinking.
on Aug 14, 2004
I agree with you that there isn't really an equivalent to Najaf in the United States... of course, that might have something to do with how removed North America is from the places its residents consider holy. Most of the holy/religious wars happened before mass migration to the United States started (thinking about the Thirty-Years War and the Crusades/reconquista mostly), so there isn't really a lot of places in America that can be considered "holy". Of all the places you stated, perhaps the Statue of Liberty might be the closest to being a sacred site, but even then, I think it still isn't the same thing.